Giving feedback to your teaching team is important for their professional growth and the success of your school. As a school administrator, your role in providing helpful and supportive feedback is crucial. Using Vygotsky’s idea of the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD), you can create an environment where feedback helps teachers grow and better support their students. This approach is especially important in global bilingual education, where cultural sensitivity is key. Here are the best ways to give feedback effectively, guided by ZPD principles.
1. Create a Culture of Collaborative Learning
Before giving specific feedback, it’s important to create a culture where feedback is seen positively and as part of collaborative learning. Encourage open communication and make it clear that feedback is a part of professional development. That includes feedback of YOUR role by the staff themselves, without fear of retaliation or any social-emotional punishment. Honestly should be rewarded and valued. It starts with you.
Tips for implementing a culture of feedback:
- Hold regular meetings where feedback and collaborative learning are standard topics.
- Encourage teachers to give peer feedback, creating a community of shared growth.
- Highlight positive outcomes from past feedback to show its benefits.
- Be culturally sensitive and adapt your feedback style to respect diverse backgrounds.
- Be aware that not all types of feedback are appropriate in public settings, even positive ones, depending on the person.
The key here is to get to know your staff so well, that you know what type of feedback they need and they accept.
2. Identify and Work Within the Teacher’s ZPD
When giving feedback, identify where each teacher’s ZPD lies – the area where they can achieve their best with the right amount of guidance. Be specific and focus on behaviors or outcomes that are just beyond their current abilities but within reach with support. This is also where motivation lies and waits to be ignited.
Tips for identifying teachers’ ZPD:
- Instead of saying, “Your lesson was good,” say, “Your use of visual supports in the math lesson kept the students engaged and aided our incoming students to understand what you were requesting from them and could be improved by incorporating more peer-led modeling.”
- Use clear examples to illustrate your points and suggest achievable next steps and don’t forget to follow up! This shows that you value their progress and pushes their own motivation.
- Consider language barriers and provide feedback whenever possible at the teacher’s language learning level.
- Listen to how they react to your feedback – short term and long term, this gives you many clues about how you can adjust your approach to the specific teacher.
- Write down your interactions so you can remember what happened and be able to follow up appropriately in future meetings with each teacher.
3. Provide Scaffolding through Balanced Feedback
Balance positive and constructive feedback to ensure your team feels valued and understands areas for improvement. Just as scaffolding supports students within their ZPD, feedback should support teachers to achieve higher levels of competence – pointing them in the right direction, not just stating what didn’t work and why.
Tips for providing balanced feedback:
- Recognize what the teacher is doing well to reinforce positive behaviors and provide a foundation for further growth.
- Offer constructive feedback in a supportive tone, focusing on improvement rather than criticism. Give them ideas on how to improve – you are in your position for a reason!
- Highlight growth potential with clear, actionable steps. Again, follow up!
- Be mindful of gender dynamics and aim to empower and give attention to all teachers with the necessary equity that a diverse team requires.
4. Be Timely to Maximize Impact
Provide feedback as soon as possible after the observed behavior or event. Timely feedback is more relevant and easier to act upon, aligning with the idea that immediate assistance can be most beneficial within the ZPD. This is not just something we should do with children, it is a human feedback necessity! But be careful, measure your words. Sometimes when we are timely, we are not careful because we don’t take the necessary time to think about what and how we need to say something.
Tips for timely feedback:
- Schedule regular feedback sessions, but also address issues or praise promptly.
- Avoid waiting for annual reviews to give feedback.
- Create time in your schedule to talk to teachers when they are not in the classroom, be available for drop-ins, and other times to be open to receive and give feedback.
- Be aware that giving feedback might be fast for you, but the conversation might extend into a conversation that needs more time. Be sensitive to the needs of your listener!
5. Engage in a Dialogic Approach
Feedback should be a two-way conversation. Encourage teachers to share their perspectives, ask questions, and express their thoughts. This fosters a collaborative environment where feedback is a mutual learning experience. Their questions point to further learning opportunities and give you a window into their thought process and how they are processing what you told them. Allow time for this exchange to happen.
Tips for engaging in a dialogic approach:
- Ask open-ended, real questions to invite discussion. “What was your rationale for…”
- Listen actively and acknowledge the teacher’s input.
- Usher in their feedback by using phrases like, “What are your thoughts on this?” or “How did you find this conversation useful?”
6. Focus on Professional Growth Within the ZPD
Frame your feedback within the context of professional development, emphasizing that growth occurs in steps and stages, much like it does for students. Highlight how the feedback can contribute to the teacher’s growth and career advancement. When possible point your feedback to their broader goals and yearly objectives.
Tips for focusing on growth:
- Suggest specific professional development opportunities that align with the feedback.
- Provide resources such as books, workshops, courses, observations of other teachers, or further conversations with you or someone else.
- Set clear, achievable goals for improvement or align with their current goals.
- Explain how you will be following up and when to set growth expectations.
7. Follow Up to Ensure Continuous Development
Feedback should not be a one-time event. Follow up to see how the teacher is progressing and offer additional support as needed, ensuring that the scaffolding provided continues to support their journey through the ZPD. Remember, YOU are the teacher’s teacher! YOU are there to see the bigger picture and to support when necessary.
Tips to ensure development:
- Schedule follow-up meetings to discuss progress.
- Seek out times and places where you can witness first-hand the teacher’s growth in a particular area. Sometimes just your presence and time is a reward on its own (as long as you have deconstructed the fear your presence brings – if not, go back to #1).
- Celebrate improvements and milestones. E-mails, cards, nods – it doesn’t have to be a formal meeting.
- Be available for ongoing support and guidance. Keep an open-door policy for your staff!
8. Use Technology to Enhance Feedback
If you have the technological capabilities at your school, use digital tools to provide timely and organized feedback, making sure it’s accessible and actionable. This aligns with Vygotsky’s emphasis on tools and signs as mediators of learning.
Tips for enhancing feedback with technology:
- Use tools like Google Classroom, Slack, Whatsapp or dedicated feedback apps to streamline communication – making giving fast feedback possible.
- Record observations and feedback digitally to track progress over time. Keep a log of your actions to evaluate if what you have done is enough or even effective based on their outcomes. Adjust as necessary.
- Use AI to translate feedback into the native languages of your teachers – that shows you care about them on a deeper level.
As you can see, effective feedback is a cornerstone of professional development and school improvement, especially when grounded in Vygotsky’s ZPD. By being specific, timely, and supportive, and by fostering a culture of open communication and collaborative learning, school administrators can empower their teaching teams to excel.
Feedback is not just about correcting mistakes but also about recognizing achievements and guiding teachers toward continued growth and success. Implementing these strategies will create a positive, constructive feedback environment that benefits both teachers and students, reflecting the best practices of scaffolding and learning within the ZPD. In global bilingual education settings, being culturally sensitive can further enhance the effectiveness of your feedback practices.
Join our interest list for the Visionary Leaders in Bilingual Education (VLBE) course, designed specifically for global early childhood and primary bilingual school administrators. Discover cutting-edge strategies, innovative teaching methods, and best practices tailored to the unique challenges of bilingual education. Sign up now to be the first to know about course updates and gain access to exclusive early-bird discounts. Don’t miss this opportunity to transform your leadership skills and make a lasting impact on your school community! Launching in 2025!
